Governance

The Incorporation Debate


Conflicts of Interest?

Jean Stockton

  • Long-time San Tan Valley resident
  • Actively involved with incorporation effort since 2014
  • Argues that incorporation gives residents more control if they distrust current leaders
  • States the current system leaves San Tan Valley outvoted by supervisors elected from other areas

Supervisor Mike Goodman

  • County Supervisor over San Tan Valley
  • Goodman lives outside the proposed boundaries and wouldn’t be part of the new town
  • Wants more amenities for youth
  • Wants families to spend less time driving and more time at home

Layers Of Government

Representative Neal Carter

  • Arizona State Representative
  • Lives near but outside the San Tan Valley boundary
  • States incorporation gives residents more direct control over services like zoning, roads and public safety
  • Carter warns future state laws may impact cities differently than unincorporated areas

Michael Hedrick

  • A San Tan Valley attorney who strongly opposes incorporation
  • Incorporation creates another government layer without guaranteeing better services
  • Primary beneficiaries are builders and special interests, not rural residents
  • His mini farm already lost rural character; incorporation will worsen this

Jim Solares Tonner

  • San Tan Valley Resident
  • County prioritizing residential growth without local planning for San Tan Valley’s economic and community services
  • Incorporation creates a city government dedicated to residents’ specific needs

Local Control

Jean Stockton

  • County approved 180 new homes despite residents wanting retail instead of more housing
  • City governance could have required road widening and better maintained urban areas
  • San Tan Valley needs more businesses and commercial zoning to match growth

DISCLAIMER

  • All respondents were interviewed
  • The views expressed herein are solely the opinions of the respondents
  • We do not favor a particular side of the debate
  • Pinal Post is publishing this content with permission from Pinal Unlocked
  • Pinal Post is not affiliated with Pinal Unlocked
  • Pinal Post and Pinal Unlocked are not affiliated with any group involved in the incorporation effort

Eirini Pajak

Pinal Unlocked